How to Choose the Right Extracurricular Activity

How to Choose the Right Extracurricular Activity

Finding the right extracurricular activity can be a game-changer for students. Best-fit activities provide a way to pursue your passions in meaningful and constructive ways. When selected strategically, extracurriculars turn into opportunities to hone skills, boost confidence, and lay the foundation for future career paths. With a variety of options available, choosing an activity that fits your interests and goals can feel overwhelming. Explore practical tips helpful for every student looking for extracurricular activities that spark their passion. 

Reflect on Your Interests 

Before jumping into a new activity, develop your extracurricular profile. Take time to reflect on what truly interests you. What are the things that genuinely interest you—activities that bring energy, curiosity, or a sense of joy? Engaging in an activity that does not satisfy your interests will not take you far. Consider making a list of your top interests, then reflect on why each one matters to you. When working on the list, ask yourself these questions: What would it take to explore it further? Is it available through your school or local community? Where could it lead you personally, academically, or spiritually? Choosing activities that align with your passions helps you grow in purpose and guides you toward long-term success. 

Understand Categories of Extracurricular Activities 

Extracurricular activities are an important factor in college admissions. Once you have a better sense of your interests, it helps to understand the different ‘tiers’ of extracurricular activities. Not all extracurricular activities carry the same weight. For example, activities that receive recognition on the national or international levels or require participation in elite programs may stand out more on a college application. Others—like leading a community initiative, participating in regional competitions, or consistently contributing to a local club—demonstrate dedication and growth over time. 

Smaller and niche groups or clubs also offer valuable experiences, especially when students take initiative or explore new interests. While not every activity carries the same weight in college admissions, each one can offer something meaningful when selected strategically. Choosing extracurricular activities solely based on their prestige tier is not advisable, but it is important to keep this information in mind as you make your decisions. 

Try New Activities (Even Outside Your Comfort Zone) 

Sometimes, the right activity is one you have not tried yet. Stepping outside your comfort zone can lead to surprising discoveries about your interests, strengths, and potential. Do not be afraid to explore something new. Even if it feels unfamiliar at first, the experience can build confidence, expand your perspective, and help you grow in ways you did not expect. 

Every new opportunity is a chance to learn—not just about the activity itself, but about yourself. Choosing to step away from an activity that does not bring fulfillment is not failure—it is a sign of self-awareness and strength. Every experience, even the ones you leave behind, helps you better understand the path you are meant to follow.

At Bishop McLaughlin Catholic High School, student life offers more than academics. It provides meaningful opportunities to grow spiritually, intellectually, and socially. Through a variety of clubs, athletics, service projects, and faith-based activities, students develop leadership skills, build community, and pursue their passions. Contact us to discover how your student can thrive at Bishop McLaughlin Catholic High School by finding the right balance in extracurricular activities that enrich their academic journey, personal growth, and long-term goals—with guidance every step of the way.